Best Italian Restaurants in Birmingham: Our Top 10
Birmingham is bursting with beautiful Italian restaurants. If you're after top-notch Italian food in Birmingham, have a look at our Top 10.
Lucarelli
Mailbox Birmingham, Royal Mail St, Birmingham B1 1RS
Embodying Italian charm, style and fine food, it will have you singing "Belissimo!" from the rooftops.
New Italian restaurant, Lucarelli in the Mailbox is wowing guests with a unique dining experience. Embodying so much Italian charm, style and fine food that it will have you singing bellisimo from their gorgeous new flower-filled terrace.
The decadently decorated 140 cover restaurant is set over two floors. The marble and gold interior, interspersed with mood lighting and large olive trees, makes it the perfect setting for an intimate and sophisticated dinner. It's a great celebrity spot to with Aldo Zilli there every Wednesday schmoozing the guests with his Italian charm and great cooking.
175 Broad Street. Birmingham B15 1DA
Rated the top Italian restaurant in Birmingham on TripAdvisor, Del Villaggio brings the authentic flavours of Italy to the heart of the city. Inspired by Italy’s sun-drenched coasts, bustling food markets, and rich culinary traditions, it sets out to create an authentic Italian dining experience for guests.
Del Villaggio uses only the finest ingredients, from ripe tomatoes to freshly sourced meats, to craft dishes that truly capture the essence of Italian cuisine. Don't miss the mouth-watering stone-baked pizzas and hearty homemade pastas. If you can make it to dessert, the signature in-house tiramisu is a showstopper!
San Carlo
4 Temple St, Birmingham, West Midlands B2 5BN
San Carlo's claim to fame lies as much in its swanky interior and top-notch service, as it does in the tasty Italian fare. If the plush seating and glitzy lights don't go to your head, that third glass of Prosecco definitely will.
Good thing San Carlo does substance as well as style. The food is expertly prepared and delicious, with mainly classic dishes and a few unusual ones. Try the Tagliolini Lobster, San Carlo’s most famous pasta dish with lobster, brandy, tomato, peas and a touch of cream.
Here's the time we met San Carlo's founding godfather, which was a pretty fun experience.
Buonissimo
1 Albany Road, Harborne, Birmingham B17 9JX
It's not all about Italian restaurants in Birmingham city centre - the suburbs are home to some real treasures. Buonissimo is one of them. Expect generous portions and delicious flavours at this neighbourhood restaurant in Harborne.
Anyone with a sweet tooth should save room for the authentic desserts. The Misto di Pasticcini is a selection of six different treats, including Sicilian cannoli, Neaopolitan pastries, and mini panettone puddings.
Fumo
1 Waterloo St, Birmingham B2 5PG
Perched proudly on a corner of St Phillip's Square, Fumo is one of those places where people go to see and be seen. The sophisticated cocktail menu and glamorous interior attract an army of fans, eager to try drinks with exotic ingredients like cayenne pepper and Turkish Delight.
But don't forget about the food. Run by the owners of San Carlo next door, Fumo serves up some absolutely cracking grub. The menu is based on cicchetti, Venice's version of tapas. So lots of plates of this and that to share and try. We definitely recommend the incredible Gnocchi Gorgonzola, served in a crispy Parmesan basket.
You can find them in Selfridges and Waterloo Street.
Tropea
27 Lordswood Rd, Harborne, Birmingham B17 9RP
Two University College of Birmingham Alumni have launched, Tropea, an Italian café by day and an Italian restaurant by night. Tropea (pronounced Tro-Pey-Ah) is inspired by the small and beautiful town on the Calabrian coast and the menu is heavily influenced by food sold on the streets of Italy.
During the day, Tropea will serve up great coffee, breakfast, pastries, toasted focaccia sandwiches and specialities such as Piadina and Panelle. In the evening, Tropea transforms into a relaxed and softly lit restaurant with a menu made up of small plates, designed to share.
Home to snacks, fresh pastas, seafood and regional specialities, the menu reflects the best and freshest of produce, from day-boat fish to venison. There's also an extensive Italian drinks list including wines from regions all over the country.
Caffè di Milano
The Arcadian, 70 Hurst St, Birmingham B5 4TD
Calling all seafood lovers, we have the perfect place for you!
Caffê di Milano is the place to get the freshest and tastiest lobster in the city. We know the saying “Italians Do It Better’ and Caffe Di Milano have surpassed themselves with their signature seafood platter.
Fresh from the lobster tank, it’s ‘tank to table’ in 10 minutes! Served up with lemon and garlic butter on a glorious platter, the humble lobster has become a more affordable delicacy.
Piccolino
Nine Brindleyplace, 2-3, Oozells Square B1 2HS Birmingham
Offering chic yet informal dining, Piccolino is a beautiful venue located in Oozels Square.
Inspired by the traditional charm and contemporary buzz of classic brasseries, Piccolino brings a true taste of Italy to its customers.
The broad menu offers something irresistible for everyone, serving a wonderful combination of both modern and classic Italian dishes.
During the summer months, the stunning outdoor terrace provides a relaxing respite in which to enjoy a classic cocktail while watching the world go by. Talk about the perfect Al Fresco dining experience!
Riva Blu
61-63 Temple Row, Birmingham B2 5DJ
Riva Blu, the restaurant, which combines the flavours of the north and the south, feels the diversity of regions and aromas.
The dishes reflect the soul and character of Italy's many different regions, using the best, well-sourced and seasonal ingredients to make sure that every dish brings you the real taste of Italy. It’s ideal to start with a bottle of wine and a slice of exquisite garlic bread that melts in your mouth. Main courses include classics such as risotto and ravioli, as well as specialities such as Sea Bass Siciliana, Lamb Cutlets and Veal Milanese. Finish the evening with limoncello andcannoli to give your palette a full flavour of Amalfi Coast. You will not be disappointed if you visit here.
Cucina Rustica
24 Ludgate Hill, Birmingham B3 1DX
For lovers of classic Italian dishes, Cucina Rustica is a standout in Birmingham's Jewellery Quarter.
Specialising in refined pasta plates and locally sourced seafood purchased fresh daily, the restaurant is known for rich flavours, generous portions, and seasonal spcials that showcase traditional Italian cooking at its best.
From crab-filled ravioli to crispy duck leg, Cucina Rustica offers a menu that balances classic Italian comfort with refined flavours. And if you can't decide, leave it to the chef with the Tris di Paste, where three different pasta dishes are specially selected to create a personal dining experience.
Located in a striking Georgian-era building, Cucina Rustica pairs its classic menu with a warm and intimate setting, blending old-school Italian charm with understated sophistication.
Vieni
41 Pitsford St, Birmingham B18 6LJ
Also in the Jewellery Quarter there's Sicilian-inspired Italian restaurant Vieni.
Ranging from barbecued whole seabass to slow-cooked ox cheek lasagne, Vieni showcases a menu built around fresh seafood, seasonal British produce, and bold southern Italian influences.
Rooted in traditional Sicilian recipes but executed with a contemporary edge, the food is made for sharing and built around bold, coastal flavours.
With dishes designed to be passed around the table, there's always room for one more at Vieni.
Author: Dine Hub Team
